Guide
The AI Manager Coaching Playbook
Using performance data, AI, and ONA to develop high-performing teams
- 11 Min Read
- 9 Chapters
- By Sam Windsor
Introduction: The coaching gap most scale-ups face
As organizations grow, managers become increasingly important to business success.
They’re responsible for developing talent, maintaining engagement, improving performance, and helping teams navigate constant change. Yet many managers step into leadership roles with little formal training in how to coach and develop people effectively.
The result is a common challenge for growing organizations: managers who are strong individual contributors but lack the tools, insights, and confidence to support employee development at scale.
At the same time, scale-ups generate more people data than ever before. Feedback, performance conversations, engagement surveys, goals, collaboration patterns, and development activity all provide valuable signals. The challenge isn’t collecting data. It’s turning that information into meaningful action.
That’s where AI can help.
Used well, AI doesn’t replace managers. It helps them identify patterns, surface opportunities, and focus coaching conversations where they’ll have the greatest impact.
This playbook explores how growing organizations can combine manager capability, people data, and AI-powered insights to build stronger teams, improve performance, and create the conditions for long-term growth.
Part 1: Why manager quality matters more than anything else
Research consistently shows that managers have an outsized impact on employee engagement, retention, and performance. Gallup found that manager quality accounts for up to 70% of the variance in team engagement. Google’s Project Oxygen identified coaching as the most important behavior of effective managers.
The challenge isn’t that managers don’t care. Most do.
The challenge is that many managers are promoted without the tools, visibility, or training needed to coach effectively. As organizations scale, it becomes harder to spot performance trends, identify retention risks, and understand what employees need to succeed.
This is where performance data, AI-powered insights, and Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) can help.
Rather than relying on instinct alone, managers can use data to identify patterns, uncover development opportunities, and focus their coaching efforts where they’ll have the greatest impact.
What the research shows
Google’s Project Oxygen analyzed thousands of employee feedback surveys and performance reviews to understand what separates great managers from average ones.
The top factor wasn’t technical expertise or operational excellence.
It was coaching.
The most effective managers help employees grow, remove obstacles, and create the conditions for high performance.
The challenge is that effective coaching requires visibility. Managers need to understand not only what employees are achieving, but how they collaborate, influence others, and contribute across the organization.
Turning insight into action
Performance data helps managers understand trends and development opportunities. Organizational Network Analysis adds another layer of insight by revealing how work actually gets done beyond the org chart.
Together, these insights help managers make better decisions, have more meaningful conversations, and support employee growth at scale.
As Joe Bast, VP of People & Operations at Thoropass, explains:
“We looked for a solution that could help us identify key talent, which would allow us to focus retention efforts on people who are mission-critical to the business.”
Using people insights to guide retention efforts, Thoropass achieved 100% retention of top performers during the Great Resignation.
For growing organizations, that’s the opportunity: better insights create better managers, and better managers build better teams.
Part 2: What AI coaching actually does
AI in performance management gets a lot of attention. Much of the conversation focuses on replacing managers.
In reality, the most valuable use of AI is helping managers make better decisions.
As organizations grow, managers are expected to make sense of feedback, goals, performance conversations, peer recognition, and development plans across multiple employees. Identifying meaningful patterns becomes increasingly difficult.
AI helps by surfacing insights managers might otherwise miss.
It can highlight:
- Who is receiving regular feedback and who isn’t
- Which goals are progressing and which have stalled
- Where feedback is specific versus overly generic
- Which employees are highly connected and influential across the organization
- Performance and development trends over time
Rather than replacing manager judgment, AI helps managers focus their attention where it matters most.
Turning data into better coaching
Performance data shows what is happening. Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) helps explain why.
By revealing how employees collaborate, share knowledge, and influence others beyond the org chart, ONA provides a more complete picture of performance and potential.
As Joe Bast, VP of People & Operations at Thoropass, explains:
“Prior to using Confirm, we didn’t have good data and accurate measurement on who is best connected, who people go to for advice, and who needs help. Organizational Network Analysis is an absolute breakthrough for performance management.”
For growing organizations, these insights help managers coach more effectively, identify emerging talent, and support employees before issues become retention risks.
Part 3: Coaching from data, not gut feel
One of the biggest challenges in performance management is that feedback is often based on impressions rather than evidence.
Vague feedback like “Sarah is a great team player” or “John needs to be more strategic” provides little clarity on what behaviors should be repeated, improved, or changed.
Effective coaching requires specificity.
Performance data helps managers move beyond assumptions by identifying measurable patterns in employee performance, feedback, goal progress, and development over time.
The ONA insight managers can’t see alone
Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) adds another layer of visibility by revealing how employees collaborate and influence others across the organization.
It highlights who people turn to for advice, problem-solving, and information sharing, often uncovering contributors and influencers that may not be visible through traditional performance reviews.
These insights can help managers identify emerging leaders, support employees who may be disconnected, and better understand how work gets done beyond the org chart.
Most importantly, they create more meaningful coaching conversations.
Instead of relying on general observations, managers can use data to explore specific behaviors, uncover development opportunities, and help employees make measurable progress.
The result is feedback that is more objective, actionable, and impactful for both managers and employees.
Part 4: Reducing bias with better data
Even the best managers have blind spots.
Performance reviews are often influenced by recent events, personal perceptions, and limited visibility into an employee’s full contribution. As organizations grow, these challenges become harder to avoid.
Common examples include:
- Recency bias, where recent performance outweighs earlier contributions
- Similarity bias, where employees who think or work like their manager are viewed more favorably
- Attribution bias, where the same behavior is interpreted differently depending on past perceptions
- Inconsistent feedback, where employees receive different types of feedback despite similar performance
The solution isn’t removing manager judgment.
It’s providing managers with better data.
Bringing more objectivity to performance conversations
AI and Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) help managers validate assumptions with evidence.
Performance data highlights trends across goals, feedback, and development over time. ONA reveals how employees contribute beyond their formal role by identifying who colleagues turn to for advice, collaboration, and support.
These insights help managers identify high-impact contributors who may otherwise go unnoticed, challenge assumptions, and make more informed talent decisions.
As Joanna Yeoh, Director of People at Nansen, explains:
“Confirm is the first tool that lets me see the behavioral side with holistic evidence. I can quickly get the information to make decisions.”
The goal isn’t to replace human judgment. It’s to give managers a more complete picture so feedback, development, and promotion decisions are based on evidence rather than assumptions.
Part 5: Turning performance data into better coaching
Most managers don’t struggle because they lack commitment. They struggle because they lack visibility.
Performance conversations are often based on limited observations, recent events, and incomplete information. AI helps close those gaps by surfacing patterns that would otherwise be difficult to see.
Organizational Network Analysis (ONA)
Traditional performance systems rely on manager observations and self-assessments.
ONA adds a different perspective by mapping how work actually happens across the organization. It reveals:
- Who people go to for advice and support
- Hidden influencers who drive results behind the scenes
- Employees at risk of becoming disconnected
- Collaboration patterns across teams
This gives managers a more complete picture of contribution, influence, and engagement.
Feedback intelligence
AI can analyze performance conversations, peer feedback, and review data to identify recurring themes and development opportunities.
Instead of relying on memory or intuition alone, managers can better understand:
- Where employees are making progress
- Which strengths consistently appear in feedback
- Areas that may require additional coaching
- Whether feedback is specific and actionable
The result is more objective, evidence-based coaching conversations.
Goal intelligence
Goals often don’t fail suddenly. They drift off track over time.
AI helps managers identify early warning signs by highlighting stalled progress, changing patterns, and emerging risks before they become performance problems.
This allows managers to intervene earlier, provide support, and keep employees focused on the outcomes that matter most.
Better data, better conversations
AI doesn’t replace managers.
It helps managers ask better questions, have more informed conversations, and make better talent decisions.
The most effective coaching still comes from human relationships. AI simply provides the visibility needed to make those relationships more impactful.
Part 6: A practical 90-day roadmap
The organizations that get the most value from AI-powered coaching don’t try to transform performance management overnight. They start by improving visibility, creating consistent data, and helping managers make better decisions.
Days 1-30: Understand your starting point
Begin by assessing your current performance management processes.
Ask:
- Are managers providing specific, actionable feedback?
- Are goals clearly defined and measurable?
- Do employees receive consistent feedback across teams?
- Where are the biggest visibility gaps?
This creates a baseline and helps identify opportunities for improvement.
Days 31-60: Strengthen your data foundation
Consistent coaching requires consistent inputs.
Focus on:
- Standardizing manager check-ins
- Improving goal-setting practices
- Increasing the quality and frequency of feedback
- Capturing collaboration and influence data through Organizational Network Analysis (ONA)
The objective is to create a more complete picture of employee performance and contribution.
Days 61-90: Coach with greater confidence
Once the data foundation is in place, managers can begin using insights to drive better conversations.
Focus on:
- Identifying employees who may need additional support
- Recognizing emerging high performers
- Spotting stalled goals before they become performance issues
- Using ONA insights to understand collaboration, influence, and engagement patterns
At this stage, coaching becomes more proactive, evidence-based, and impactful.
Start small, scale what works
The most successful organizations don’t implement new processes everywhere at once.
They begin with a pilot group, establish manager habits, measure results, and expand over time.
The goal isn’t more data.
The goal is helping managers have better conversations, make better talent decisions, and create stronger teams.
Conclusion: Better coaching starts with better visibility
Manager effectiveness is one of the biggest drivers of employee engagement, performance, and retention.
Yet many managers are expected to coach, develop, and retain talent with limited visibility into what is actually happening across their teams.
AI helps close that gap.
By surfacing patterns across feedback, goals, performance conversations, and collaboration networks, managers can make more informed decisions and have more effective coaching conversations.
Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) adds another layer of insight by revealing how work actually gets done across the organization. It helps leaders identify hidden contributors, strengthen collaboration, and better understand the informal networks that drive performance.
The goal isn’t to replace manager judgment.
It’s to give managers the data they need to coach with greater confidence, support employee development more effectively, and build stronger, higher-performing teams.
The organizations that combine strong leadership with better talent insights will be best positioned to attract, develop, and retain the people who drive growth.
“By using Confirm, we now know who the influencers are, the high and low performers, who needs help, and what to do to keep the best.”
Joe Bast, VP People & Operations, Thoropass
See what your managers might be missing
The best coaching conversations start with better insights.
Confirm helps People leaders and managers identify top performers, uncover hidden contributors, spot retention risks, and coach employees with greater confidence.
By combining performance data, AI-powered insights, and Organizational Network Analysis (ONA), Confirm gives leaders a clearer view of how people contribute, collaborate, and influence outcomes across the business.
With Confirm, you can:
- Identify high performers and emerging talent
- Surface hidden influencers across the organization
- Detect coaching and retention risks earlier
- Improve calibration and performance conversations
- Give managers actionable insights before every 1:1
Book a demo
See how Confirm helps scale-ups build stronger managers, retain top talent, and make better people decisions.
By Sam Windsor
Articles by SamKeep reading
• 35 min read